Smithword vs Scrivener: which writing app is right for you?
Smithword vs Scrivener: Scrivener organises your manuscript, Smithword keeps you writing consistently. Here's which writing app is right for you.
If you're an aspiring author, you've probably heard of Scrivener. Scrivener is a writing tool that helps you organise and draft a complex manuscript. You might not have heard of Smithword, but we're about to change that today. Because if you're a writer who struggles with consistency, you might not need a place to draft your manuscript, and instead you might need something to actually help you stay consistent.
Although this is a comparison piece, before I get into it, I would argue that this isn't a fair comparison, because both tools are aimed at different things (by the end of this article, you might actually want both). One is for drafting, the other cultivates your writing practice by helping you stay consistent. Smithword does this by planning out your book for you, and breaking it down into small, manageable tasks. So if you're someone who struggles with staying consistent when planning, drafting or editing your book, stay tuned to find out why Smithword might be the app for you.
What is Scrivener?
A drafting tool and manuscript-organising app for Mac, Windows and iOS. One-time purchase (roughly $60 Mac/Windows, cheaper on iOS; major version upgrades cost extra), not a subscription.
What is Smithword?
Smithword is a free app, designed to make writing less overwhelming. It does this by breaking your book down into small, manageable tasks and helping you create a healthy relationship with your writing. Smithword addresses the habit side of writing. It gives structure to your process, so if you're overwhelmed by where to start, it hands you a clear task at every stage from drafting to editing.
Scrivener vs Smithword: a quick comparison
Best for
- Scrivener: organising and drafting a complex manuscript
- Smithword: actually writing consistently and finishing a draft
Core idea
- Scrivener: a powerful place to put your words
- Smithword: a plan that gets you writing, one small task at a time
Learning curve
- Scrivener: steeper, lots of features
- Smithword: minimal, it tells you what to do
Handles missed days
- Scrivener: it's just a document, that's on you
- Smithword: re-plans around you automatically
Low-energy days
- Scrivener: no specific support
- Smithword: low-energy mode with a lighter task
Formatting and publishing
- Scrivener: powerful (with a learning curve)
- Smithword: not its job
AI writing
- Scrivener: no
- Smithword: no, every word is yours
Platforms
- Scrivener: Mac, Windows, iOS
- Smithword: iOS and web
Price
- Scrivener: one-time purchase, roughly $60
- Smithword: free
Why Scrivener might not be for you
If you're struggling with writing consistently, battling writing blocks, or you have no idea how to fit writing into your life, a tool that's essentially a blank document waiting to be filled can feel overwhelming, and it's unlikely to inspire much writing confidence or creativity.
Why Smithword might not be for you
If you're writing regularly, have a good grasp of your story, and don't struggle to sit down and write consistently, you might not need Smithword.
So which one should you choose?
Choose Scrivener if you're struggling to organise your book. If you're already writing consistently and just want a way to keep everything in one place, Scrivener is a great tool.
Choose Smithword if you're struggling with consistency. If you battle to stay on track, you can't seem to finish a book, or you keep stopping and starting your writing projects, Smithword is designed to help with all of these. The app is built on psychology and neuroscience research to help you overcome writing blocks and stay consistent. And it plans your book for you, so every time you sit down to write, you know exactly what to work on.
Ultimately, the two tools do different things, and you might find that you actually need both: Smithword to help you stay on track, and Scrivener as the place you write.
The most important thing is finding something that helps with the thing that's keeping you stuck. If it's organisation, choose Scrivener. If it's consistency, choose Smithword.
FAQ
Is Smithword a replacement for Scrivener?
Not exactly. Scrivener is a writing and organising workspace. Smithword is a consistency and planning app that gets you writing in small regular sessions. Some people use both, for different jobs.
Does Smithword have formatting and publishing tools like Scrivener?
No. Smithword focuses on helping you write consistently and finish a draft. For formatting and publishing, you'd use a dedicated tool.
Is Scrivener hard to learn?
It has a real learning curve. It's very powerful, but many writers find it overwhelming at first. If you want something simpler that just tells you what to write next, Smithword is designed to be the opposite.
Does either app use AI to write for you?
Neither Scrivener nor Smithword writes your book for you. With Smithword specifically, every word stays yours. It helps you show up and write, rather than generating text.
What if I miss a week of writing?
With Scrivener, your document just sits there, and picking back up is on you. Smithword re-plans around missed days, so you have a clear way back in without starting over or trying to catch up.